Best Sandwich Makers

Review & Comparison, Last Update September 17, 2020
Nothing can be compared to a lip-smacking hot sandwich for breakfast. Therefore, we believe all fans of nutritious tasty sandwiches will appreciate our best sandwich makers review. Check it out and find the model that suits your preferences most. ...Read more ...Read less
BEST 2020
PROS
CONS
OUR VERDICT
SANDWICH TYPES AND FORMS
NUMBER OF SANDWICHES AT A TIME
BREAD TYPES
CONTROLS AND INDICATORS
USABILITY
DIMENSIONS AND WEIGHT
COATING
CLEANING
Warranty
 
PROS
A handy and easy-to-use sandwich maker at a reasonable price. Interchangeable plates are easily removed by means of cool-touch handles, significantly easing the unit cleaning and operation.
CONS
Light indicators are a bit dim.
OUR VERDICT

Distinguished by the branded quality and extremely easy to use, this sandwich maker from Tefal with dual functionality will An affordable 2-in-1 kitchen appliance will become an exceptional choice for any family kitchen. Whether you have a smaller sweet tooth in you family or a diet follower, it has something to offer to anyone. 

detailed parameters
SANDWICH TYPES AND FORMS

Triangle sealed toastie sandwiches

NUMBER OF SANDWICHES AT A TIME
4
BREAD TYPES

Sliced sandwich bread or any other square-cut loaves

CONTROLS AND INDICATORS
Power on & Ready for cooking light indicators
USABILITY
2 sets of interchangeable plates (for sandwiches/for waffles), Vertical storage, Cord wrap, Latched handles
DIMENSIONS AND WEIGHT

12.7" x 11.9" x 6.8"

4.5 lbs

COATING
Non-stick plate surface
CLEANING
Removable plates are dishwasher safe
Warranty

1-year limited

PROS

Thanks to a floating lid design, this model can easily accommodate even thicker sandwiches, meanwhile, ensuring even and uniform all-side cooking with no hot or cold spots. 

CONS

The cooking plates are prone to scratches. 

OUR VERDICT

If you are a fan of bigger juicy sandwiches generously stuffed with a number of ingredients, this Deluxe sandwich maker from Proctor Silex is for you. A thought-out design will let you have your nutrient-packed appetizing treats ready in less than 5 minutes while a stainless steel unit body with ceramic cooking plates will ensure long-lasting service life.

detailed parameters
SANDWICH TYPES AND FORMS

Square breakfast sandwiches or panini-style sandwiches

NUMBER OF SANDWICHES AT A TIME

1 or 2

BREAD TYPES

Sliced sandwich bread and any other loaves up to 3 inches thick

CONTROLS AND INDICATORS

Power on/preheat lights

USABILITY

Locking handle, Floating lid, Lid lock, Upright storage, Durable stainless steel housing

DIMENSIONS AND WEIGHT

8.7" x 12.2" x 4"

4.8 lbs

COATING

Non-stick plate surface

CLEANING

Wipe clean with a damp cloth

Warranty

Amazon's 30-day return policy

PROS

With the 25490A, you will be able to prepare any sandwiches you like, thanks to the cooking plates and rings included.  Just place a slice of bread in each bottom ring, top it with bacon and/or cheese, add an egg, and off you go. 

CONS
The working surface gets very hot, so, you need to use pot holders.
OUR VERDICT

The Hamilton sandwich maker will be an excellent solution for families that look to buy a versatile piece suitable for making not only toasties but also frying eggs, grilling meat, and even making pancakes. Thanks to its dual cooking surface, it's fit for just about any task.

detailed parameters
SANDWICH TYPES AND FORMS
Breakfast sandwiches
NUMBER OF SANDWICHES AT A TIME
1 or 2
BREAD TYPES
Kaiser rolls such as bagels and English muffins
CONTROLS AND INDICATORS
Red POWER Light, Green PREHEAT Light, Audio beep timer (0.5-5 min)
USABILITY
Sliding cooking plates to fry eggs, Convenient handle
DIMENSIONS AND WEIGHT

6" x 10.5" x 8"

4.8 lbs

COATING
Non-stick coating
CLEANING
Removable rings are dishwasher safe
Warranty

1-year limited

PROS

High-quality non-stick plates coating will ensure perfect golden crust and prevent scorching, meanwhile making the unit cleanup a breeze. It's enough to simply wipe the plates with a damp cloth once they are cool.

CONS

The white body is prone to stains. 

OUR VERDICT

Simple to use and compact, the Proctor Silex sandwich maker will let you cook deliciously warm delicacies for the whole family in a matter of minutes without putting in much effort. You can be sure the unit will soon become your favorite and take a decent place in your kitchen arsenal. 

detailed parameters
SANDWICH TYPES AND FORMS

Triangle sealed toastie sandwiches

NUMBER OF SANDWICHES AT A TIME

4

BREAD TYPES

Sliced sandwich bread or any other square-cut loaves

CONTROLS AND INDICATORS

Power on, Preheat lights

USABILITY

Compact, Upright storage, Lockable handle

DIMENSIONS AND WEIGHT

11" x 10" x 4.64"

3.7 lbs

COATING

Non-stick plate surface

CLEANING

Wipe clean with a damp cloth

Warranty

1 year 

PROS

Grill plates feature special grease channels that ensure efficiently fat and oil drainage, thus, making your meal healthier and making the plate cleaning a breeze.

CONS

During the first use, there might be some specific smell.

OUR VERDICT

The strength of the Black and Decker WM2000SD is its impressive versatility. Not only does it function as a traditional sandwich maker, it also can serve as a whole mini cooking station, enabling you to make yummy toasties, waffles and even grill steaks.

detailed parameters
SANDWICH TYPES AND FORMS

Triangle sealed toastie sandwiches

NUMBER OF SANDWICHES AT A TIME

4

BREAD TYPES

Sliced sandwich bread or any other square-cut loaves

CONTROLS AND INDICATORS

Power on/preheat lights

USABILITY

Interchangeable plates for a waffle maker, grill, and a sandwich maker, Cool-touch handles with lock, Upright storage, Non-skid feet

DIMENSIONS AND WEIGHT

9" x 9" x 4"

6.25 lbs

COATING

Non-stick plate surface

CLEANING

Removable plates are dishwasher safe

Warranty

2-year limited

Tefal SW6100 EZ

Enjoy the Branded Quality

Tefal is a reputed French brand producing cookware and smaller home appliances, which include electric kettles, toasters, hand blenders, mixers, irons, hair driers, pans, and more, that are popular and highly ranked among customers all over the world. What distinguishes Tefal's products is that they all boast solid design quality and offer the best of technological innovations. The Tefal SW6100 EZ hasn't become an exception.

Even though a sandwich maker is usually void of gimmicky features, this model stands out from the rest. It's made of first-class materials that are extremely durable and is highly resistant to wear and tear, so you can expect it to serve you for a long time without showing any sign of damage and deformation. At the same time, using the Tefal SW6100 EZ is no brainer. It comes with handy LED lights that will notify you when the unit is turned on and when the plates have reached the optimal temperature and are ready to use. For your convenience, the Tefal SW6100 EZ's fitted with handles so you can move it and check on the cooking process without the risk of burning your hands plus there's a special compartment for cord storage, allowing you to neatly store it away when not in use.

We should also point out that the Tefal SW6100 EZ is a compact and pretty lightweight unit. Therefore, you can store it in a cupboard and easily take it out whenever you need it. Moreover, it can also be stored upright, which makes it perfect for owners of the smallest kitchens, where every inch matters. On top of that, the cooking plates are removable and dishwasher-safe, so you will be able to easily clean them after use without having to scrub off the remnants of food.

Review of Tefal SW6100 EZ Waffle Sandwich Maker

... and Extended Functionality

When it comes down to the functionality, the Tefal SW6100 EZ allows you to make up to 4 triangle toastie sandwiches at a time, making it a fantastic option for those who love pocket sandwiches. The unit's compatible with sliced sandwich bread (or any other square-cut loaves) and will work with just about any filling, including ham, cheese, tuna, beans, tomatoes, and many more. So, you can experiment and jazz up sandwiches with any kind of ingredients you or your family love.

Aside from sandwich plates, the unit package also includes a set of waffle plates to make fantastic crispy waffles for breakfast, dessert or snack time. Serve it with caramel, Mapel syrup, jam, wiped cream or any other sweet topping and be sure your kids will swallow it at one gulp. In case your children want to try their hand at roasting those yummy pouches and crunchy waffles too, it's advisable to do that together in order to exclude the risk of burns.

To wrap the whole thing up, if you look for a reliable top-quality sandwich maker that will serve you for years to come, you’ll be hard-pressed to find a better option than the Tefal SW6100 EZ.

Tefal SW6100 EZ Waffle Sandwich Maker in the use

What customers say about this product

Key Specs

I have looked for a waffle maker with removeable plates for years! I was so happy to find this item. It works great and the waffles do not stick to the surface of the plates. I am so glad I bought this.

Size & Weight

I like how compact it is also. It's easy to store.

Control

The plates snap out with a push of a button.

Features

Temperature seems adequate. Would recommend it. The price is right and it appears to be well made.
 

Proctor Silex 25415 Deluxe

For Cafe-style Sandwiches at Home

A warm sandwich stuffed with chunky fixings toasted to perfection is a simple and cozy food suitable not only for breakfast but also for quick meals and those lazy family dinners when you are not eager to cook. Those hearty big treats with delicious melted stuffings packed in between crusty pieces of bread or soft rolls are what make numerous snack bars and cafes so welcoming places. Want to have a chance to make cafe-style yummy delicacies at home? If so, the Deluxe sandwich maker from Proctor Silex is for you.

Unlike ordinary sandwich makers designed to make sealed toastie pouches, this model is built a bit differently. Instead of relatively shallow cooking plates with dividing ribs to make 4 smaller triangle toasties, this appliance comes with perfectly smooth cooking plates and overall, is pretty deep to accommodate much thicker sandwiches. It is large enough to handle either two square sandwiches (twice the size of a regular triangle toastie) or a single big panini-style sandwich. On top of that, thanks to a special floating lid design, you can pile your sandwiches really high to make them thick (up to 3 inches) and juicy. While cooking, the lid lock will keep the plates tightly closed making sure your treats will come out evenly cooked from both sides, with the stuffing delicately warm and cheese perfectly melted. Hence, whether you want a couple of common cheese and ham sandwiches with a dual condiment for breakfast or plan to experiment with ciabatta fixings, the Proctor Silex Deluxe can do this and much more.

Review of Proctor Silex 25415 Deluxe Hot Sandwich Maker

Tested and Proven Reliability

Buying a kitchen appliance, we expect it to serve us for long. The Proctor Silex Deluxe sandwich maker will fully live up to your expectations. Though fairly simple in use, the model is solidly built and designed to withstand active daily use while maintaining consistently high performance, which is proved by numerous successful operation tests the unit has passed in the manufacturer’s engineering laboratory. A stainless steel body not only looks very up-to-date and will add a modern twist to your countertop but also is very durable and resistant to mechanical damages. At the same time, ceramic cooking plates are food-safe and boast excellent non-stick qualities. As such, they are also a snap to clean. Even though the plates are not removable, it is enough to wipe them down with a damp cloth to remove some food residues.

All in all, the Procter Silex Deluxe sandwich maker is a dependable and fairly simple appliance that will let you toss off pro-grade sandwiches in the comfort of your own kitchen and experiment with recipes to impress your family and guests.

Proctor Silex 25415 Deluxe Hot Sandwich Maker in the use

Additional Info

    Manufacturer


 

Hamilton Beach 25490A

Make Your Sandwich Your Way

Are you one of those passionate sandwich lovers who can’t imagine anything but a multi-layered sandwich for breakfast? If so, the Hamilton Beach 25490A sandwich maker has something to offer to you and other sandwich fans in your family.  

Casting a quick glance at the appliance is enough to guess it is different from those models meant to grill toastie pouches. The Hamilton Beach 25490A is designed to make two sandwiches at a time, yet, be sure a single sandwich will suffice for you to feel full. Fitted with two ring-shaped plates and two egg plates, this model allows using bagels, English muffins, and other round rolls instead of toaster bread and, what is more important, it will let you make your sandwiches your way. 

If you are a fan of a healthy lifestyle or follow some kind of low-calorie diet while your spouse prefers a substantial protein-packed breakfast, this amazing sandwich maker can make two individually customized sandwiches simultaneously. Just add any fresh or precooked ingredients to get a tasty multilayered sandwich for a consistent home breakfast or on-the-go bite. You can even add an egg in between using a sliding cooking plate or put pancakes instead of bread and pour syrup to a finished sandwich to make a fancy breakfast for your little one. On one hand, a round form may seem a kind of limitation. But on the other hand, this tiny inconvenience is rewarded with an opportunity to experiment with foods and flavors every day. More than that, you use a bare cooking surface to toss off a traditional egg and fried bacon breakfast.

Review of Hamilton Beach 25490A Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker

Easy-to-use and Easy-to-clean

This functional dual sandwich maker is extremely handy and easy to use and boasts intuitive controls. One of the light indicators shows when the unit is on while another will light when the plates are heated to the necessary temperature. A countdown timer will make an audible beep to let you know when your perfectly assembled sandwiches are ready to eat. 

If you've ever made sandwiches at home you know that it’s a multi-step process resulting in a number of pans to clean. The Hamiton Beach sandwich maker will save you that cleaning fuss. Both working surfaces are ring assemblies and sliding plates are non-stick coated, so, there will be no scorched or burned foods to scrub off. Besides, all removable parts are dishwasher safe, hence, no grease to clean. And the working surfaces are enough to be wiped with a damp cloth. 

When it comes to storage, you can easily store the unit on a kitchen shelf or in a cabinet or place it on the countertop for continuous access in case you plan to use it on a daily basis.  

All things considered, practical, functional, and versatile, the Hamilton Beach sandwich maker has all chances to become your favorite kitchen appliance. It will cater to any dietary needs and meet any tastes.

Hamilton Beach 25490A Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker in the use

VIDEO
Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker 25490

What customers say about this product

Size & Weight

The maker is very compact for easy storage.

Key Specs

I have used it for about a week now, and made a bunch of sandwiches.

Control

When it reaches zero, there's a clear and audible beeping that even for my lousy hearing was easy to hear even at a distance.

Features

And all the cooking surfaces are non-stick. It's as easy, if not easier, than cleaning a frying pan.
 

Proctor Silex 25408Y

No-frills Functionality

Toasty hot pouches stuffed with cheesy and creamy fillings and exuding a combo of mouth-watering aromas. There's hardly anything better to have for breakfast or as a quick meal or evening snack. Sounds tempting? Then you may want to consider a sandwich maker from Proctor Silex, which while having no extra frills, does a great job of making delicious custom sandwiches. However, before going into details, let's start with its design.

The Proctor Silex 25408Y is a rather compact model, which can be stored upright, in a cupboard or straight on your countertop without eating too much of its space. At the same time, the cooking surface of the device is accommodating enough and can easily fit two large sizes of sandwich bread (or any square cut loaf) letting you make four triangle toasties at a time. So, you can use any type of bread and explore many different breakfast sandwich alternatives.

In terms of performance, the Proctor Silex 25408Y is no slouch either. It heats up almost in the blink of an eye and when it reaches the optimal temperature, the indicator light turns green so you can see when it's time to cook. When in use, the unit handle remains cool to the touch and keeps hot cooking plates securely locked, thus, eliminating the risk of injuries.

Review of Proctor Silex 25408Y Sandwich Toaster

Tasty Bites Without Mess

What makes a really good toasty? It’s a perfect golden crust on the top, you're right. However, it's not the only thing. What is also important is the filling, or, to be more precise, the amount of it: the more stuffing you put inside, the more delicious your sandwich will be. The problem is, not all sandwich makers are deep enough to hold all that stuffing inside without letting melted ingredients leak out of it, which while being not a huge drawback is rather inconvenient nevertheless. The Proctor Silex, however, is not one of them.

What distinguishes the Proctor Silex 25408Y is that it has very deep plates, so you can put as much filling as you want inside without worrying about it leaking out. When pressing bread slices together, the unit makes sure the edges of toasty triangles are perfectly sealed so there's nothing to "crawl" out of it. One other benefit of the Proctor Silex 25408Y is that it has a high-quality non-stick coating, which prevents the food from sticking to the plates and makes it easy to remove sandwiches after cooking. As a result, all your sandwiches will be perfectly cooked and browned to perfection and there will be little cleaning to do. Speaking of which, simply let the unit cool down a bit and wipe it clean with a damp cloth and the device will be ready for next use. 

All in all, the Proctor Silex sandwich maker is a reliable and functional basic model that will add to any kitchen arsenal and let you enjoy your favorite warm treats whenever you want.

Proctor Silex 25408Y Sandwich Toaster in the use

Additional Info

User Manual     Manufacturer


 

BLACK + DECKER WM2000SD

A Handy Multi-tasker

Modern kitchen appliances greatly expand our cooking abilities, enabling us to hone our cooking skills to a professional level and cook pretty much any common restaurant dish in a home kitchen. Moreover, some of those kitchen gizmos perfectly embrace the functionality of several devices. And a sandwich maker from Black and Decker is one of those amazing multi-taskers.

At a glance, the unit looks like any common electric sandwich maker and is really fairly simple in use. Besides, it is very compact and won’t take much space even on smaller kitchen countertops. Yet, don’t let this seeming simplicity fool you since the functionality of this model goes beyond a humble sandwich maker. What makes the Back and Decker stand out is as many as three sets of interchangeable cooking plates included in the package. Along with standard sandwich plates, you will also get waffle and grill plates. Thus, you’ll be able not only to make 4 toasties with a warm cheesy stuffing squeezed in between two crunchy slices of bread at a time but also to cook deliciously soft waffles that taste great with a variety of dressings and make a perfect base for a range of desserts and grill a whole choice of foods.

So, no child will resist Belgian-style waffles with a ball of ice-cream and chopped fruit or nuts. And if you need a plate full of sealed pouch sandwiches or homemade hot dogs for a family movie night or want to toss off a quick and healthy dinner with grilled chicken breasts and veg, the Black and Decker will also come to help. The number of fishes you can use this little cooker for is close to endless, you name it.

Review of BLACK + DECKER WM2000SD 3-in-1 Morning Meal Station

... With a Thought-out Design

As versatile and functional as it is, the Black and Decker 3-in-1 sandwich maker is also distinguished by a well-thought design. The unit body is manufactured of plastic and stainless steel combo. While plastic keeps it cool to the touch for easy appliance opening and closing without the risk of burns even when the plates are still hot, the metal contributes to the exterior durability and adds attractive modern accents. Light indicators on the top panel will inform you when the plates are heated to the cooking temperature and the handle lock will keep them securely closed for convenient and compact unit storage in the upright position. Besides, small non-skid feet will not only ensure the appliance stability on any surface but also keep it elevated to prevent countertop heat damages.

Speaking of the cooking plates, they are all non-stick coated and dishwasher safe. So, cleaning won’t be a hassle at all. And the grease run-off channels on grill plates will let you neatly collect and dispose of fat and oil and prevent any countertop mess.

To conclude, with the Black and Decker, you’ll get not just a sandwich maker but a whole mini cooking station that will extend your kitchen functionality and save you the need to purchase a grill and a waffle maker separately.

BLACK + DECKER WM2000SD 3-in-1 Morning Meal Station in the use

Additional Info

    Manufacturer


 

What Is a Sandwich Maker?

Sandwiches are popular and highly appreciated all over the world. A common sandwich looks like two pieces of bread filled with dainty ingredients. However, a variety of sandwiches that can be made is, in fact, unlimited, because you can use pretty much any stuffing you like, be it meat, ham, cheese, bacon, salad leaves, tuna, veggies, etc., as well as experiment with different types of bread to make your sandwich taste better. With sandwiches, it's easy to release your inner potential and let your creativity go really wild.

Of course, making sandwiches is easy and can be done using a microwave oven, for example. However, the best way is to use an electric sandwich maker. Similarly to a microwave, it'll heat the ingredients and give your sandwich a nice crispy crust. But unlike it, a sandwich maker will do it quicker and better.

To help you choose a sandwich maker that will work best for you, we've picked five top-selling models from renowned brands. Check them out and make your choice.

Meanwhile, almost no breakfast is complete without a cup of tea or coffee. Therefore, we'd also recommend checking out our reviews of coffee makers, French presses, and electric kettles.

What Features to Compare

Types of Sandwiches

One of the first things to consider when choosing a sandwich maker is what type of sandwiches and how many of them the appliance can make at a time. Although you are free to customize your sandwiches by experimenting with the stuffings and the bread type, three most popular types, which can be included in a sandwich maker, are regular breakfast sandwiches, triangle sealed toasties and well-known Paninis.

When it comes to breakfast sandwiches, these are usually made of bagels or English muffins and are filled with traditional breakfast ingredients such as sausage, ham, roasted bacon, fried eggs, and salad leaves. Naturally, sandwiches of this type are very nutritious and can substitute a whole breakfast meal, thus, making them a favorite option for busy people who rarely have time for cooking.

Sandwich makers designed to make triangle sealed toasties normally feature two ribbed cooking plates to make up to 4 treats at a time and work with square-cut or sliced sandwich bread. What makes them attractive is that they seal ingredients between the slices of bread, thus, forming a so-called pocket sandwich, which is delicious and convenient to eat on the go as well.

However, among the three, panini is perhaps the most popular type. It allows using pretty much any bread and can be stuffed with just about any ingredients your heart desires. The only tradeoff is that they don't usually make more than one sandwich at a time. That said, the treat will come out big enough to be split into several bite-size sandwiches.

Controls and Usability Features

Next, consider the appliance controls and usability features. Typically, sandwich makers are pretty easy to use and offer fairly intuitive controls, all being straightforward and easy to get the hang of from the get-go. In fact, they come fitted with only a temperature control knob and on/heat light and sound indicators.

The usability of sandwich makers directly depends on their functional versatility. Notably, many models come with several interchangeable plates expanding their functionality to cover that of a waffle maker and even a portable electric grill. Thus, ribbed grill plates will let you roast steaks, sausages, poultry, seafood, veggies, and even burgers for scrumptious and nutrient-packed multi-layered sandwiches and a whole variety of other delicious homemade treats. At the same time, waffle plates are a real find for families with kids and dessert lovers since delicately soft and crispy Belgian waffles perfectly pair with a wide choice of toppings and make an irresistibly tasty dessert.

Whether fitted with interchangeable plates or equipped with built-in cooking plates, modern sandwich makers boast non-stick cooking surfaces (either Teflon or ceramic) for quick and easy unit cleaning. Some more sophisticated appliances even have an adjustable plate slop to drain oils and juices while cooking and a drip tray to collect that grease.

Dimensions and Design

The last but not the least parameters to check are the appliance design and overall dimensions. Mostly, the sandwich makers are pretty compact units that can be vertically stored in a common kitchen cabinet. Special handle locks keep the plates securely closed for safe and damage-free storage.

Sources:

1. Alina Bradford What I learned Using a Breakfast Sandwich Maker, CNET. January 5, 2016.

2. Breakfast Sandwich, Wikipedia. May 27, 2016.

3. Panini (sandwich), Wikipedia. July 25, 2016.

4. Felicity Cloake How to Make the Perfect Grilled Cheese Sandwich, The Guardian. November 5, 2014.

5. Megan Gordon Hot and Melty: 10 Delicious Grilled Sandwich Recipes, Kitchn. March 11, 2013.

6. Eve O'Sallivan Best Toasted Sandwich Recipes, Smartcooky. February 23, 2015.

Other reviews
Comments
0 Comments

Your comment was successfully sent

Error! Please try again later