Best Butter Machines for Wholesome Bread Spreads

Review & Comparison, Last Update September 4, 2017
Nothing tastes like homemade food, and it is hard to find any other meals as healthy and nutritious as those cooked by yourself. From now on you can complement your meals or quick snacks with a freshly-made spread prepared with the help of one of these excellent butter machines. ...Read more ...Read less
BEST 2017
PROS
CONS
OUR VERDICT
COOKING OPTIONS
DRIVE MECHANISM
CONTAINER CAPACITY
CONTAINER MATERIAL
CONVENIENCES
ACCESSORIES
WARRANTY
 
PROS

An ergonomic overflow sensor alongside ScentLock™ lid will prevent your ingredients from spilling out during mixing and preparing

CONS

It will take some time to get used to adjusting the temperature settings. 

OUR VERDICT

With this Magical Butter Extractor MB2E machine, you can infuse herbs and spices into butter and oil to create wholesome spreads, dressings, and even skin care products.

detailed parameters
COOKING OPTIONS

Oils, Butter, Tinctures

DRIVE MECHANISM

Electric

CONTAINER CAPACITY

5 cups

CONTAINER MATERIAL

Stainless steel

CONVENIENCES
  • ScentLock lid, 
  • Overflow sensor, 
  • Colorful led indicator lights, 
  • 5 temperature modes, 
  • 4 time modes, 
  • Clean mode
ACCESSORIES

  • LoveGlove™(silicone)
  • PurifyFilter™ (nylon)
  • Cookbook with recipes

WARRANTY

Amazon’s 30-day return policy

PROS

This manual butter maker has a capacious 6.7-cup container that allows churning up to 1.5 lbs of butter in one go.  

CONS

Some parts of its crank mechanism are made of plastic. 

OUR VERDICT

If you are tired of the bland and flat taste of store-bought spreads, try making homemade butter yourself that will not only taste better but will also be free from harmful additives and preservatives! With this awesome device, it will be done in a few minutes.

detailed parameters
COOKING OPTIONS

Butter

DRIVE MECHANISM

Manual

CONTAINER CAPACITY

~6.7 cups (up to 4 cups of cream)

CONTAINER MATERIAL

Glass

CONVENIENCES
  • Wide-mouth jar, 
  • Wooden handle, 
  • Efficient crank mechanism
ACCESSORIES

Butter maker only

WARRANTY

2 years

PROS

Thoughtful design and user-friendly orange knob ensure easy cleaning in case nuts clog up the unit. The included chute cap will help protect its parts from the dust. 

CONS

Its oil dispenser can only hold 1-2 spoonfuls of oil. 

OUR VERDICT

If you are looking for a durable, reliable, and user-friendly appliance to pamper your family with freshly-made nut spread? Nostalgia Electrics Peanut butter maker is the one to go for!

detailed parameters
COOKING OPTIONS

Peanut butter

DRIVE MECHANISM

Electric

CONTAINER CAPACITY

Nut Bin: ~0.7 lbs

Butter container: ~1 cup 

CONTAINER MATERIAL

Plastic

CONVENIENCES
  • Orange knob mechanism for easy cleaning
ACCESSORIES
  • Butter container lid
  • Chute cap 
  • Oil dispenser
  • Instruction with recipes
WARRANTY

1 year

PROS

This model, equipped with a durable stainless steel crank mechanism and four-paddle plastic dasher makes the process of churning delicious homemade butter simply a breeze. 

CONS

A silicon gasket on the lid might wear out with time.

OUR VERDICT

With this marvelous Kilner Butter Churn, you will discover a simple way to make butter that tastes amazingly different from the one you can buy in the store. A glass butter dish is also available.

detailed parameters
COOKING OPTIONS

Butter

DRIVE MECHANISM

Manual

CONTAINER CAPACITY

4.2 cups (up to 3 cups of cream)

CONTAINER MATERIAL

Glass

CONVENIENCES
  • Wide-mouth jar, 
  • Wooden handle, 
  • Efficient crank mechanism
ACCESSORIES
  • Instruction with recipes
WARRANTY

Amazon’s 30-day return policy

PROS

The PBM500 butter machine features an aluminum auger that will grind any kind of nuts and will take no time and effort to produce nutritious nut spreads.

CONS

This model is a bit loud in operation. 

OUR VERDICT

This professional butter maker is an ideal solution for making the most delicious, super healthy, and nutritious desserts with peanut butter.

detailed parameters
COOKING OPTIONS

Peanut butter

DRIVE MECHANISM

Electric

CONTAINER CAPACITY

Nut Bin: 1 lbs

Butter container: ~1.25 сup

CONTAINER MATERIAL

Plastic

CONVENIENCES
  • Oil dispenser, 
  • Two-position (On/Off) power switch, 
  • Three-position (On/Off/Reverse) grind switch
ACCESSORIES
  • Butter container lid
  • Instruction with recipes
WARRANTY

1 year

What is a Butter Machine?

It is getting harder and harder to find healthy natural products in supermarkets these days. To prolong the shelf life of edibles and make them look and smell better, manufacturers use a variety of food additives and preservatives. The problem is, they not only prevent the food from spoiling but also may prevent you from enjoying good health and well-being. No wonder, more and more people start preparing wholesome foods and beverages at home without dangerous and harmful additives. Naturally, the market eagerly responds to the consumers' demands and there appear more and more helpful appliances on sale for healthy homemade cooking (e. g. juicers, soy milk makers etc.). If your family members cannot imagine their mornings without a fresh toast with nutritious nut butter, we advise you to invest in a butter machine for preparing healthy and delicious homemade spreads. You will be impressed with the taste and flavor of the freshly made delicacy!

If you are looking for a handy device that will help you cope with almost any kitchen task, please have a look at our review of countertop blenders.

What Features to Compare

Type

Before choosing a butter machine, you should consider which type you need. Peanut butter machines were designed to make healthiest nut butter; dairy butter machines allow churning cream into delectable homemade butter. There are also multifunctional devices that allow infusing spices and herbs into butter and oils for preparing flavorsome spreads and sauces and even skin-care products. The unit can be equipped with either electric of manual drive mechanism; the first type is easier to operate: just plug the device in and switch its power button and it will do the job. Besides, some appliances allow heating oils to enrich them with herb extract. On the other hand, contemporary mechanical devices ensure quick and efficient churning and empower you to control the process for getting the desired consistency. 

Capacity and Material

The next important tip is your chosen model nut bin and container capacity: the larger it is, the more butter you can make in one go. Today, you can find models with 1 up to 5 cups capacity.

Plastic, glass, and stainless steel are the most common materials used for making butter machines. It is advisable to choose an item with a transparent nut bin and container for better control on the grinding/churning process and timely consistency adjustment. 

Conveniences

To ensure the most effective and comfortable butter making, machines are usually equipped with a variety of features. Most of them boast thoughtful design to provide easy cleaning and maintenance to save your time and nerves and ensure a durable and efficient performance of the unit. Several preset cooking modes will be a welcome feature if you are going to cook butter, oils, and desserts following versatile recipes. If you have decided on a mechanical device, it is important to choose one allowing comfortable loading/dispensing foodstuffs. Fast and efficient churning with minimum efforts is a huge plus as well. Most models come with easy-to-follow instructions for hustle-free use, a great number of recipes, and helpful tips and ideas for cooking deliciously healthy desserts.

...Read more ...Read less

Magical Butter MB2E

The Evolution of the Botanical Extractor

As the company name suggests, it manufactures products that allow you to make wholesome butter and oils at home, as if by magic, extracting essential nutrients from various spices and healing herbs. This fantastic botanical extractor is perfect for making:

  • Oil. Pour 2 to 5 cups of olive, coconut, sunflower, corn, or other vegetable oil. Add 0.25-0.5 oz of botanicals per cup. Preset the temperature according to the recipe from the included cookbook and press the 'Oil' button.
  • Butter. The recipe is pretty much the same, just add butter instead of oil and press the 'Butter' button after adjusting the temperature. Please note that it is recommended to pre-melt the butter before you add it to the pitcher. 
  • Tincture. Place 2-5 cups of vegetable glycerine or grain alcohol and add 0.25-0.5 oz of healing herbs. Adjust the temperature and prep time. After 8 hours you will get a fantastic natural tincture. Please, carefully follow the manufacturer's instructions. 

We cannot help mentioning an ergonomic LED display that allows you to monitor cooking progress and create a special atmosphere in your kitchen. Thanks to a built-in overflow sensor, pitcher contents won't spill during cooking. A reliable ScentLock lid and integrated digital thermostat ensure accurate temperature control.


Review of Magical Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine

Self-Cleaning Feature

One more welcoming feature of the butter maker is its self-cleaning function. After use, unplug the device and fill the pitcher with water (between MIN and MAX level markings), add some dish soap and secure the lid. Plug the appliance in and press the Clean button. When the cleaning cycle is completed, disconnect the cord, carefully rinse the pitcher to remove any remaining soap, and let it dry. 

Magical Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine in the use

Useful Accessories

In the box, you will find the following additional accessories for the most convenient cooking:

  • PurifyFilter™. This handy device will help you retain sediment of your health elixir, filter your botanical extracts, allow natural juicing, and a lot more. Made of durable nylon, it will serve you faithfully for a long time.
  • LoveGlove™. This glove, made of premium-quality silicone, will prevent pitcher contents from coming into contact with your hand, which is important for safe and sanitary preparations as well as a good quality of the prepared extract. Moreover, it will help avoid burns when straining hot liquids. 
Detailed review of Magical Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine

How About Homemade Bread?

Fresh butter tastes good but it is too fat to be eaten on its own. Thus, it is best to enjoy it with a slice of bread. Trust us, there is nothing that tastes better than homemade butter with freshly baked bread! Get one of these wonderful bread makers to make fragrant, airy, and fluffy pastries to go with flavored self-made butter spread. 

Magical Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine application

Additional Info

User Manual     Manufacturer


Magical Butter MB2E
Magical Butter MB2E
 

Paderno World Cuisine Fresh Butter Maker

Excellent Homemade Butter in a Few Minutes

If you are looking for a reliable device to churn natural homemade spread, the Paderno Butter Maker is just what you need! This handy, convenient, and modern kitchen appliance will allow you to make delicious dairy butter following the old tried-and-true method, just the way our grandparents did. All you have to do is pour some cream into its glass container and secure the lid with a crank mechanism. The latter will turn the contents into butter as you rotate its ergonomic handle. 

In addition, this model features a durable and long-lasting design. There are some plastic parts, but main gears and crank mechanism are made of high-quality stainless steel for its effective performance and long use. As for the bottom jar, it is made of thick glass and boasts 6.7 cups capacity. Taking just 5 to 8 minutes (depending on cream amount), the churning process becomes a piece of cake. Please, keep in mind that for hustle-free operation, the manufacturer recommends adding maximum 4 cups of cream, otherwise it will get difficult to rotate the handle and turn the crank. 

Treat yourself and your family to a natural home-made delicacy and you will never want to go back to flat and artificial store-bought spreads.

Review of Paderno World Cuisine Fresh Butter Maker

Ergonomic Container for Your Ultimate Convenience

The butter maker is equipped with a reliable rectangular-shaped jar to ensure convenient and durable use. Thanks to such thought-out design, the item will stay stable and sturdy on your countertop. For better stability and to avoid sliding on the surface, we advise you to spread a cloth under the jar over your working surface. 

Paderno World Cuisine Fresh Butter Maker in the use

Few Helpful Tips

Take note of the following tips to prepare a delightful homemade butter. 

  • Use cream with at least 30% fat content.
  • For the perfect texture and taste, proper temperature of the cream (65 degrees Fahrenheit) is essential. It is recommended to take it out of the fridge and let it sit in the room temperature for two hours before churning. 
  • After solids and whey (white liquid) are separated, place them into a fine mesh strainer and rinse with cold water. 

By following these tips, it will be easy for you to make a wholesome treat to feast your eyes and senses!


Detailed review of Paderno World Cuisine Fresh Butter Maker

Crunchy Toasts with Homemade Butter... Sounds Delicious!

If you love crunchy buttered toasts accompanied with your favorite coffee drink, please have a look at our toasters and espresso machines reviews.  

Paderno World Cuisine Fresh Butter Maker application

Additional Info

    Manufacturer


Paderno World Cuisine Fresh Butter Maker
Paderno World Cuisine Fresh Butter Maker
 

Nostalgia Electrics NBM400

Enjoy Delicious Taste of Homemade Peanut Butter

Freshly made nut butter is a nutritious and filling treat appreciated by kids and adults alike. It contains vitamins and micronutrients essential for our health. With the Nostalgia Electrics NBM400, you can make peanut butter just like that! Simply fill its 0.7 lbs bin with chopped nuts, lock the lid and switch the appliance on. In a few seconds, a freshly-made spread will be dispensed into its nut butter container. 

The device is equipped with a handy oil dispenser so you can adjust the consistency, adding as much oil as you need depending on nut type and your recipe. By turning the unit's agitator, you can mix nuts inside the nut bin and keep them moving into the grinder. Ergonomic and effective, the device boasts an elegant design and will look fantastic in your kitchen. If you do not intend to finish all the butter in one go, cover the container with the included lid for convenient storage in the fridge. By the way, the shelf life of such butter is about 1-2 months, so you have nothing to worry about. It will surely last throughout the entire week and you will have a fresh homemade delicacy to treat your loved ones to for breakfast. 

Review of Nostalgia Electrics NBM400 Electric Peanut Butter Maker

Easy to Clean

For a lasting and efficient performance of the unit, it is important to regularly clean the nut grinder that may get clogged inside with solid pieces of nuts. Twist the orange knob on the housing (clockwise) and clean the nut grinder under warm water with some non-abrasive cleaning liquid and wipe it with a piece of cloth. You can also use a soft brush or tooth stick to thoroughly clean hard-to-reach places if needed. To protect the machine from dust, we advise you to use a handy chute cap included in a package. 

Nostalgia Electrics NBM400 Electric Peanut Butter Maker in the use

A Variety of Nuts to Grind

This 150-Watt capacity device is thoroughly designed and well-equipped for easy grinding of any kind of nuts you fill the bin with. You can turn peanuts, almonds, hazelnuts, cashews, macadamia nuts, and even sunflower seeds into a toothsome and nutritious spread! Just keep in mind it was designed for processing shelled and chopped nuts and works best for grinding roasted kernels. 

Detailed review of Nostalgia Electrics NBM400 Electric Peanut Butter Maker

Some Ideas for Creating Tasty Desserts

If you want to treat yourself and your family to a healthy, nutritious, and yummy breakfast, how about crunchy waffles (so-easy-to-bake with a quality waffle maker) with nut butter on top? You can also get a handy donut maker to cook mouth-watering treats that taste delicious with freshly-made nut butter. 

Nostalgia Electrics NBM400 Electric Peanut Butter Maker application

Additional Info

User Manual     Manufacturer


Nostalgia Electrics NBM400
Nostalgia Electrics NBM400
 

Kilner Butter Churn

New Life to the Old Good Things

Founded in 1842, the Kilner company is famous for its high-quality glass jars for preserving and pickling numerous fruits and vegetables. To help you expand the range, quality, and variety of your home produce, the company has introduced the Butter Churn for making fresh and delicious butter. 

Let's have a look at this fantastic Kilner butter churner. Its stylish retro design will add a vintage touch to your kitchen. Its elegant wooden handles ensure a comfortable grip and easy operation. Moreover, the machine is equipped with a reliable stainless still crank mechanism. The model has 34 oz (4.2 cups) capacity allowing you to churn about 3 cups of cream to produce more than 1 lb of excellent homemade butter. The yield of the product may vary depending on the percentage of fat content in cream. 

With this awesome butter churner, you will be able to make ample butter for your entire family in one go. Anyway, the process lasts for about 10 minutes, so you can produce another batch in a breeze if you wish to. A step-by-step instruction guide and a wide selection of recipes are included. Yet, if you think you need even more inspiration, you can check out the company's official website, where you can find even more recipes and useful tips. 

Review of Kilner Butter Churn

Easy Cleaning

It is advisable to wash both the jar and the crank mechanism as soon as your butter is ready since dairy products can rapidly go off. The glass jar is absolutely dishwasher-safe. However, if you wish to avoid wear and tear of silicone parts of the lid, hand wash in warm soapy water is recommended. Note, that regular dishwashing can cause the butter machine performance to deteriorate and impair the fitting of the lid. Here is one more helpful tip: although this handy appliance boasts stainless steel mechanism, it is still better to wipe all parts with a dry cloth and let them air-dry for a while after washing.

Kilner Butter Churn in the use

Thoughtful Design for Effective Churning

To provide an effective performance of the unit, the manufacturer has equipped it with 4 silicone paddles. Its elaborate design allows hassle-free and efficient churning even if the container is full. 

Detailed review of Kilner Butter Churn

Homemade Ice-Cream in 30 Minutes!

How about preparing a scrumptious cold dessert at home? With one of these high-quality, durable, and reliable ice cream makers, it will take minimum time and effort! All you need for it is cream, which is the main ingredient of this well-loved treat. Add some flavors to it and you can treat all your family to these wholesome delicacies on any occasion. 

Kilner Butter Churn application

Additional Info

    Manufacturer


Kilner Butter Churn
Kilner Butter Churn
 

Nostalgia PBM500

Professional Peanut Butter Maker

This unique Nostalgia Electrics product is a professional device for preparing appetizing homemade peanut butter. First of all, a die-cast aluminum auger in its nut chute will easily ground peanuts, almonds, cashews, macadamia nuts, hazelnuts, sunflower seeds, and more. It is easy to achieve the desired butter consistency thanks to an ergonomic oil dispenser. In addition to a power switch, the appliance features a grind switch with a reverse option that will help prevent nut pieces from clogging and make grinding process more efficient. Ergonomic non-skid feet will prevent the appliance from sliding over the countertop and reduce vibration during the unit's operation. Another welcome feature of the device is its simple cleaning. All removable parts are easy to wash using warm soapy water and non-abrasive cloth. Do not forget to let them dry after cleaning. Use a damp cloth to wipe clean the housing. Here you are, your butter churner looks as good as new and is ready for grinding a new batch of nuts!

Review of Nostalgia PBM500 Professional Peanut Butter & Nut Butter Maker

Capacious Nut Bin

Far to often, peanut butter machines are equipped with very small nut bins; as a result, you can't prepare a sufficiently large portion in one go to treat all your family members to this yummy, creamy, and healthful delicacy. Luckily, this wonderful model has a large and capacious nut bin, capable of holding up to 1 lb of chopped nuts. Moreover, its nut chute is located high enough to use it with either the included 1.25-cup butter container or other dishware.

Nostalgia PBM500 Professional Peanut Butter & Nut Butter Maker in the use

Recipe of Honey Peanut Butter

Surprise your nearest and dearest with new charming flavors! You will find plenty of easy-to-follow recipes in the included instructions. Here is one of them.

Ingredients: peanut butter (2.5 cups), vegetable oil (2 Tbsp.), honey (2 Tbsp.). 

Preparation: put shelled and chopped peanuts into a nut bin; add oil into an oil dispenser. When your peanut butter is ready, add honey and mix well (you can use a hand blender for faster and more efficient results). 

To cook enchanting chocolate dessert, add a few tablespoons of melted chocolate. 

Detailed review of Nostalgia PBM500 Professional Peanut Butter & Nut Butter Maker

A Small Tip for Better Taste and Flavor

Peanut butter has a 1-2-month shelf life when stored in the fridge, so you can make a bigger batch to have a chance to spread on your bread whenever you feel like having a quick snack. To ensure its excellent taste, professional chefs recommend putting peanut spread into a microwave oven for 15-20 seconds before serving. This will help your spread reach the desired consistency and release a superior mouth-watering flavor. 

Nostalgia PBM500 Professional Peanut Butter & Nut Butter Maker application

Additional Info

User Manual     Manufacturer


Nostalgia PBM500
Nostalgia PBM500
 

FAQ:

Q: How to select a butter machine? 

A: That depends on your needs. Some devices produce dairy butter, others were designed for making nut spread or even making food and cosmetic oils. Today, you can get a manual appliance that allows you to churn butter in less than 10 minutes. It is a wonderful device to involve your kiddies in the kitchen and cultivate healthy eating habits. Peanut butter makers designed to grind nuts are usually AC-powered. When selecting this kind of device, you should also consider its wattage as well as its nut bin and container capacity. 

Q: What is the difference between peanut butter and dairy butter machines?

A: They are made for different purposes: dairy butter machine is used to churn cream until it turns into butter; nut butter machine grinds kernels turning them into nutritious nut spread. Whichever you choose, you will be able to make a wholesome treat to accompany your homemade pastry and enjoy the most delicious and nutritious breakfast with your family on a daily basis.

Q: What kind of nuts can I grind in a peanut butter machine?

A: As a rule, this kind of appliance works with all types of nuts. However, you should check the information provided by the manufacturer to make sure you get the one that meets your needs. You can experiment with the butter consistency by adding more or less oil and flavors and mixing them with various ingredients. Ultimately, it all depends on your fantasy! Don't be afraid to get creative! If you feel like you need a helping hand, most manufacturers include helpful recipe books. 

You should also keep in mind that most peanut butter machines were designed to grind chopped nuts. No need to mention that the nuts need to be shelled.

Q: Can I make cosmetic oils and lotions with the help of butter machine?

A: Yes, you can. There are appliances designed especially for this purpose. Just add vegetable oil with some herbs and the device will heat the ingredients so that essential micronutrients and vitamins will be released into the oil and thoroughly mixed. Please, carefully follow manufacturers instructions while making your own healing elixirs and be careful with filtering the hot liquids. 

Q: How long does homemade peanut butter last?

A: This natural treat contains no food additives so its shelf life is shorter than that of its store-bought edibles. However, it lasts long enough from 1 and up to 2 months so you can easily prepare some butter in advance and leave it in reserve. Just do not forget to put it in the fridge. 

Q: What cream should I buy for making butter at home?

A: It is recommended to use fatty cream with at least 30% of fat content (whipping cream or double cream). You can experiment with tastes and consistency. Enjoy watching a magical transformation of cream into scrumptious butter!


Sources:

1. Lydia Stephens Health Benefits of Peanut Butter, LIVESTRONG.COM. January 28, 2015. 

2. How to Make Homemade Butter, wikiHow. 

3. Brandy O’Neill How To Make Homemade Butter For Unbelievably Fresh Flavor, SheKnows. August 4, 2016. 

4. Emma Christensen How To Make Homemade Peanut Butter, The Kitchn. January 15, 2014. 

5. Michelle Profis 19 Sinfully Sweet Peanut Butter Recipes, Country Living. February 16, 2017. 

6. Churning (butter), Wikipedia. February 5, 2017. 

7. The emergence of dairy butter WebExhibits.

8. 8 Health Benefits of Peanut Butter Care2.

9. Hali Bey Ramdene What's the Difference Between European and American Butter? The Kitchn. March 3, 2016.

10. Grace Dickinson Going Nuts — For Nut and Seed Butters, That IsToday's Dietitian. September 2013.

Other reviews
Publish Date: 2017-06-26 12:28:59